Go Back   London Fixed-gear and Single-speed > Bikes & Bits


 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 12th August 2008   #1
Merak
 
Merak's Avatar
Saddle angle's

Right. Straight to the point. I am getting discomfort in what can only be described as the pubic bone area after a couple of hours on my geared bike. A definite shrinkage of manhood allied with unnerving numbness.

Incidentally I have an Arione on the geared bike and old skool flites on my other bikes.

Has anyone else had similar problems? Is saddle angle a personal thing? I havent really encountered this before.

I have always had my saddles dead level set with a bead. I think I might try and angle the nose down a bit.

The Arione is new to me but comfortable in every other area.
  quote   reply
Registered users don't see adverts. Signup or signin to hide them.
Old 12th August 2008   #2
hippy
 
hippy's Avatar
If you have no problem using the Flite. Put a Flite on the bike.
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #3
Shinscar
 
Shinscar's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by hippy View Post
If you have no problem using the Flite. Put a Flite on the bike.
but dont you have yours angled straight up?
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #4
hippy
 
hippy's Avatar
Only when I'm ramming it in your arse.
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #5
Merak
 
Merak's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by hippy View Post
If you have no problem using the Flite. Put a Flite on the bike.
Yep thought about that, I like the Arione though. Perhaps its Physiology. The Arione is dead flat tip to tail whereas the Flite is kind of contoured.

I will have a go at the tipping the nose slightly then revert to the Flite if I have no joy.
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #6
Shinscar
 
Shinscar's Avatar
yeah try tipping it up alittle... and also getting it so the hardest part of you arse is on the hardest part of the saddle. I've got a little boney arse... and recently got a brooks... which was originally, how do i put it............... FUCKING AGONY... but after moving the saddle back a bit its alllll good!
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #7
andyp
 
andyp's Avatar
I've got an Arione on one of my bikes and found that angling the front down slightly turned it from an uncomfortable saddle into the most comfortable saddle I've ever ridden.
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #8
Shinscar
 
Shinscar's Avatar
on another note i have a nitto seat post and its bloody fantastic for setting angles...just wanted to throw that out there. tiny little thing but great.

Last edited by Shinscar; 12th August 2008 at 17:12.. Reason: 2 fantastics dont make a right
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #9
Courant
Let us know how you get on - I too am very happy on my flites but am curious to try the Arione sometime, just to see what it's like and see what all the fuss is about. Have you tried the aliante too? Apparently v.similar in curvature to a flite.

Also, aside from angle, have you got the saddle height right? An old bike I once had came with a nasty flat-ish saddle and that did similar things to my bits - in the end, dropping the saddle 5mm made all the difference. But not enough to stop me replacing it after a couple of months!

Courant
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #10
nimhbus
 
nimhbus's Avatar
i have a black Arione for sale, just £20, you heard me, £20
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #11
stevo_com
 
stevo_com's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shinscar View Post
tiny little thing but great.
If I had a penny for every time I've used that in conversation..............
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #12
Merak
 
Merak's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp View Post
I've got an Arione on one of my bikes and found that angling the front down slightly turned it from an uncomfortable saddle into the most comfortable saddle I've ever ridden.
Just the kind of feedback I was looking for. I will give that a go.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Courant View Post
Let us know how you get on - I too am very happy on my flites but am curious to try the Arione sometime, just to see what it's like and see what all the fuss is about. Have you tried the aliante too? Apparently v.similar in curvature to a flite.



Courant
I haven't heard of the Aliante, will check it out. I will let you know how I get on with the different position of the Arione.



Quote:
Originally Posted by nimhbus View Post
i have a black Arione for sale, just £20, you heard me, £20
How dare you! peddling your wares on my post :)
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #13
Courant
Quote:
Originally Posted by nimhbus View Post
i have a black Arione for sale, just £20, you heard me, £20
Hmmm, interesting. Seriously?! How many miles has it seen?

Courant
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #14
hippy
 
hippy's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by nimhbus View Post
i have a black Arione for sale, just £20, you heard me, £20
Murtle's? I thought you liked it?
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #15
deadly fanny pack
 
deadly fanny pack's Avatar
saddles should be perfectly horizontal, do it with a spirit level to be sure!


If its uncomfortable, handle bar reach, saddle height, frame size etc are to blame!

Sit on saddle, feet on pedals. Cranks horizontal. Hang a piece of string from the top of your Tibia, it should line up vertically with the pedal spindle.

If it doesnt you need to slide your seat foward or backward.

Last edited by deadly fanny pack; 12th August 2008 at 22:16..
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #16
JOL
 
JOL's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by deadly fanny pack View Post
Sit on saddle, feet on pedals. Cranks horizontal. Hang a piece of string from the top of your Tibia, it shoul line up vertically with thour pedal spindle.
Sounds like a sermon.
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #17
BringMeMyFix
 
BringMeMyFix's Avatar
Sermon on the mount, init.
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #18
nimhbus
 
nimhbus's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Courant View Post
Hmmm, interesting. Seriously?! How many miles has it seen?

Courant
no idea. i did about 50 on it. it's in decent condition
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #19
nimhbus
 
nimhbus's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by hippy View Post
Murtle's? I thought you liked it?

i did. i very gaily bought another one that matches my bike.
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #20
hippy
 
hippy's Avatar
He should've given it to me.. I would've dished it out some proper abuse.

As for the poster above, saddles _don't_ have to be dead flat. It's just a good starting point.
Also KOPS (knee over pedal spindle) where you do that plum bob thing is also just a bit of a bodged starting point.

http://www.sheldonbrown.com/kops.html
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2008   #21
Dammit
Quote:
Originally Posted by nimhbus View Post
no idea. i did about 50 on it. it's in decent condition
Let the bidding war commence!

If Courant bails I'll have it.
  quote   reply
Old 13th August 2008   #22
daveray
 
daveray's Avatar
Saddles are totally horses for courses. One man's meat is another's poison. Personally I'm all about the cut-out. Fizik say they are bad for you. Toupe's are, in my opinion, awesome, Turbo's awful. I'm sure the popularity of the turbo would suggest others disagree. Hippy's right. They don't have to be level but it is a good starting point. Brooks generally ride a bit better a bit nose up, Rolls a bit nose down.
Your weight should be on your sit bones and fairly little elsewhere, it sometimes helps to sit a bit further back than one might naturally do. That plumb bob/patella/spindle equation will do a lot for pain elsewhere, but I imagine, little for saddle discomfort. Also more than a 8-10inch drop from saddle to bars is from a medical standpoint getting into danger territory if you fancy riding very far and keeping your girlfriend. This is slightly different on TT style scenarios where pressure on the pedals takes it off the saddle.
The nose down a bit may offer some relief but if I remember rightly fiziks are pretty flat and smooth which means one will be prone to sliding forward which is no good for efficiency, comfort, or the @rse of your shorts.
If the flites fit, stick with them, try your mate's saddles and ask if your shop has lenders, some more race oriented shops will have a box full of try outable seats. A seatpost which is infinitely adjustable (as opposed to ones with a toothed gripping head) is a must IMHO and good shorts make a world of difference as well. Sorry for such a long winded answer.
  quote   reply
Old 13th August 2008   #23
Platini
 
Platini's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Merak View Post
saddle angle's
  quote   reply
Old 13th August 2008   #24
Merak
 
Merak's Avatar
Damn you and your apostrophe knowlede Platini. I knew that didnt look right.:)
  quote   reply
Old 13th August 2008   #25
Platini
 
Platini's Avatar
Knowledge, didn't (sometimes they are needed...)
;-)
  quote   reply
Old 13th August 2008   #26
nimhbus
 
nimhbus's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dammit View Post
Let the bidding war commence!

If Courant bails I'll have it.

it's not new, i got it off murtle first. it's fine though, very serviceable.
  quote   reply
Old 13th August 2008   #27
hippy
 
hippy's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by daveray View Post
Hippy's right.
Rep :)
  quote   reply
Old 13th August 2008   #28
Courant
nimhbus, game on, I'll just send you a PM.

Courant
  quote   reply
Old 13th August 2008   #29
nimhbus
 
nimhbus's Avatar
SOLD


the Official LGFSS Arione continues it's epic journey
  quote   reply
Old 13th August 2008   #30
Platini
 
Platini's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by nimhbus View Post
sold


The Official Lgfss Arione Continues It's Epic Journey
Ffs!
;-)
  quote   reply
Old 13th August 2008   #31
pistaboy79
 
pistaboy79's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Merak View Post
Yep thought about that, I like the Arione though. Perhaps its Physiology. The Arione is dead flat tip to tail whereas the Flite is kind of contoured.

I will have a go at the tipping the nose slightly then revert to the Flite if I have no joy.
Pay attention to stretching the hip flexors. Too much tension there brings the pelvis into anterior tilt, bringing the pubis down onto the saddle...
  quote   reply
Old 13th August 2008   #32
nimhbus
 
nimhbus's Avatar
it's true, they say the Arione breaks in bit on the flexy bits. the LGFSS arione was a bit more comfy than my brand new one for this reason.
  quote   reply
Old 13th August 2008   #33
Skully
 
Skully's Avatar
oooh I wonder when I will get to have it... and how much it will cost!? I might get it for the price of some pork scratchings in 2011...
  quote   reply