Go Back   London Fixed-gear and Single-speed > General


View Poll Results: LFGSS Book Good thing/Bad Thing
Yes, great idea, I want one 19 59.38%
No, bad idea 9 28.13%
I've got creative skills, I'll help out 8 25.00%
I know people who'd want to sponsor such an endeavour 2 6.25%
Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 32. You may not vote on this poll

 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 24th June 2008   #1
cornelius blackfoot
 
cornelius blackfoot's Avatar
LFGSS Book: A Year in the life of a Forum

Been thinking about this for the last couple of days, and am posting this up to find out whether it'd be worth the pain of doing.
With the launch of Fixed magazine (lovely idea and execution guys) got me to thinking that I'd really like to document in a physical, non internet way the forum as it is now. We've been going a year, there's been a shit load of great threads, arrospok, epic fail to name a few, a host of great rides, London to Brighton, Southend, Cambridge, Oxford, Dunwich Dynamo, Bridges, Secret London, Monopoly, and forum drinks established throughout the big smoke.

So I thought it'd be good to produce a book to show what a truly great forum this is, using the skills and the ingenuity of the creative forumengers amongst us, we've got great designers, photographers, writers, and everything else to make a great book, plus a whole years worth of material in the threads to start off with.

Right now I think we can do it in two ways, one we could put together a book through Iphoto, quick, relatively simple, and not that expensive maybe? or two we can try and get it done professionally, obviously the more you make the cheaper the costs will be, and to try and keep the costs down we could try for sponsorship from someone or other.

So what do you think? Good idea, bad idea, let me know in the poll, also put your name down to help put the bastardbook together if the idea ever gets off the ground.
  quote   reply
Registered users don't see adverts. Signup or signin to hide them.
Old 24th June 2008   #2
dogsballs
 
dogsballs's Avatar
thinking too much corny. do more ridin!
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #3
teddy
 
teddy's Avatar
why don't we put together a website that documents threads and rides and... oh.
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #4
tomasito
 
tomasito's Avatar
I'm a literary agent, so if you guys felt you wanted to do something through a regular trade publisher (rather than self-publishing) I would be happy to pitch it to the houses...but I think if that was the case there would need to be more of a hook to make it interesting to non-forumengers. A decent book on fixed gear cycling generally would be worth considering.
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #5
BoBoB
 
BoBoB's Avatar
Nice idea corny, my mates done a book through iphoto the other day for their round the world trip, was a really nice touch i thought. It only cost £15 i think....
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #6
B
theres also bobbooks or whatever it's called that'll do small runs of hardbacked books. No idea how good the printing is though...

B.
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #7
JOL
 
JOL's Avatar
I'd be up for helping with this.

Be nice to do a proper book with a bit more control though.
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #8
dogsballs
 
dogsballs's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by BoBoB View Post
Nice idea corny, my mates done a book through iphoto the other day for their round the world trip, was a really nice touch i thought. It only cost £15 i think....
i thought you changed to moobies???
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #9
cornelius blackfoot
 
cornelius blackfoot's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by JOL View Post
Be nice to do a proper book with a bit more control though.
thats what I was thinking, but I wanted to gather a bit more feedback/support.
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #10
VanUden
 
VanUden's Avatar
I can right stuff.

To those who aren't sure or might see this as an attempt to commercialise something pretty free and organic - I'd say the following. Who would you rather create something like this (because as with any 'movement' for want of a better word it's happening now and will continue to do so); people you know who genuinely love what they/you are into? Or, sharp, opportunist, people not that bothered about the scene who only see the dollar sign and may not care that much about accuracy or quality of content?

Just a thought for you.
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #11
pajamas
 
pajamas's Avatar
In theory dude I think it's a nice idea. But on the other hand it seems - dare I say it? - retroactive? is that the word? This is the technology we've got - it would be like playing chess by post, no?

I just think it would be difficult to convey the (fairly fundamental) forum vibe once you start bringing threads into it. A lot of them twist, turn and spiral out of control because of the role time and technology play in the process. In a way..."you had to be there.."

If you're talking about a record of rides and drinks, cool - but you miss the day-to-day bollocks everyone reads which makes them feel the sense of community we have.

Why not just have a "Best of London fgss" section?

not trying to be harsh or anything man, just not really seeing how it would work or why it would be necessary.
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #12
BringMeMyFix
 
BringMeMyFix's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by VanUden View Post
I can right stuff.
Irony. Haha. Or was it...?
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #13
31t®um
 
31t®um's Avatar
don't let tommy write anything !!
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #14
VanUden
 
VanUden's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by BringMeMyFix View Post
Irony. Haha. Or was it...?
Bussted :(
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #15
cornelius blackfoot
 
cornelius blackfoot's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by pajamas View Post
In theory dude I think it's a nice idea. But on the other hand it seems - dare I say it? - retroactive? is that the word? This is the technology we've got - it would be like playing chess by post, no?

I just think it would be difficult to convey the (fairly fundamental) forum vibe once you start bringing threads into it. A lot of them twist, turn and spiral out of control because of the role time and technology play in the process. In a way..."you had to be there.."

If you're talking about a record of rides and drinks, cool - but you miss the day-to-day bollocks everyone reads which makes them feel the sense of community we have.

Why not just have a "Best of London fgss" section?

not trying to be harsh or anything man, just not really seeing how it would work or why it would be necessary.
all valid points, but as I was saying yesterday, not sure if I said it to you, but the forum's growing pretty fast, you just have to look back at some of the resurrected posts from march 2007, when its just six or seven posters pushing views back and forth to the amount of views/poster on any given subject now, to realise the speed of change.

I want the book to capture the forum as it is now, to take the best bits of it and put it in a form which any member of the forum who has a copy can look at, and with a little bit of nostalgia say I was there when...

the book isn't supposed to supplant the forum, its supposed to be the best bits of the forum given physical form, a place where we collate the threads, images, rides, that show the forum as it is/was, at this point in time.

There is no real need to do a book, apart from the fact that I think it'd be fun to do and to own, and I want to have some record of this forum, when I'm no longer actively using it, or if it doesn't exist anymore. And I think that even if people aren't aware of it now, that we'll want to have some record that we were here, we were part of this really vibrant, funny, twisted, scatalogical forum/community, before its just archived pages on a server somewhere, which will take you forever to find because you forgot what that thread with the funny aerospoke photos was called and you haven't logged on for the last couple of years, so your password is a mystery etc etc etc...
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #16
pajamas
 
pajamas's Avatar
scatalogical? I haven't found that stuff yet. I knew there were VIP threads..

yeah I dig what you're saying actually. Fair labour of love though, harnessing all this and encapsulating it will be a challenge.

I think you're talking about an editorial team, meetings etc.

could be good.
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #17
CHUG_IT
 
CHUG_IT's Avatar
Coffee table book stylee would be nice. In this day and age of websites and digital this and that I think it would be nice to have a large format, chunky book with big pictures, short texts on the countless rides that have gone on, West/South/East/Central 'scenes' within london, extra-curricular stuff that people get up to (Trixies etc)...

I personally think this could be a goer. I'm down to help.
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #18
teddy
 
teddy's Avatar
know what'd be good? the londonfgss guide to riding fixed. booklet that answers all the questions all you newbies have on buying/setting up your first fixed gear or ss bike, how to pimp up your slave bike and how to do minor repairs. available for £10 from the website. proceeds go to running the website.
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #19
Object
 
Object's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by cornelius blackfoot View Post
I want the book to capture the forum as it is now, to take the best bits of it and put it in a form which any member of the forum who has a copy can look at, and with a little bit of nostalgia say I was there when...
But we live this forum. I've got the scars to prove it.
Hope you're not planning on leaving us anytime soon big fella.
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #20
cornelius blackfoot
 
cornelius blackfoot's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by teddy View Post
know what'd be good? the londonfgss guide to riding fixed. booklet that answers all the questions all you newbies have on buying/setting up your first fixed gear or ss bike, how to pimp up your slave bike and how to do minor repairs. available for £10 from the website. proceeds go to running the website.
dude thats a great idea, ten notes might be a bit much, but its doable, and a valuable resource, and I'm pretty sure we could produce an online version of it, which would sit on the forum and we can point out to those new to the forum

Quote:
Originally Posted by Object View Post
But we live this forum. I've got the scars to prove it.
Hope you're not planning on leaving us anytime soon big fella.
no not planning on leaving anytime soon, and living the forum is the best way, but for everyone else there will be the book
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #21
villa-ru
 
villa-ru's Avatar
with the threat of having to pay a tenner I bet the search function would get alot more use!
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #22
JOL
 
JOL's Avatar
Having tangible records of things is still important I think. I'm a lover of tactile objects as well as all the digital stuff going on at the moment.

I know it sounds old-school but if 'internet-things' were to go haywire all this could be lost. Also a record of all the crap we have got up to over the year would be great.

AND, if the 'bubble' were to burst which I'm sure it will at some point, the forum could eventually die out in it's current form (As VB's other forum is/was?). To have records of all the great stuff and rubbish that goes on here would be a really nice thing.

My 2c.
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #23
Hammo
I got dem MAD skillz n'ting.

This is a good idea!
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #24
hippy
 
hippy's Avatar
You can use some of my material.. and a bargain at only £10 per post :)
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #25
Jontyponty
i think this idea is wack. no offence, but why make a book of a forum? i know you've sort of explained it above but i'm still confused. can't u just ask vb to give u the entire forum on a dvd or something?
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #26
photoben
 
photoben's Avatar
Perhaps just a one-off book made along this idea as a fund-raiser for the forum?
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #27
cornelius blackfoot
 
cornelius blackfoot's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jontyponty View Post
i think this idea is wack. no offence, but why make a book of a forum? i know you've sort of explained it above but i'm still confused. can't u just ask vb to give u the entire forum on a dvd or something?
jonty, I'm not offended, slightly protective maybe but not offended, if you don't understand the explanation, ask me and I'll endeavour to make the reasons behind the idea clearer, you're welcome to your point of view, but explain to me why you would want to have a dvd, turn on a tv, and show your friends/family this really great forum that you're apart of, full of insightful posts, and little mpegs, and photochops. they'd get bored in a heartbeat,whilst you navigate through menus to show them that one little bit that made you wet your pants the first time you read/saw it. But give them a book, and they can flick through it, put it down, pick it up again, look at the photo's, read the funny things we've spent so long crafting, at their own pace.

The book is supposed to be something substantive, you hold it, you love it, you own it, it goes with you, it can be shared, given away, taken back, lost, found, bent, broken, repaired, much like the bikes we ride. You can't do that with the forum in its natural internet habitat.
Thats why I want to do this, I'm not trying to recreate the forum on paper (well maybe just a little bit) what I want the book to be is a time capsule for the best of this forum, a yearbook, an annual even.
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #28
Shinscar
 
Shinscar's Avatar
Corny, heard your thoughts on this on Sunday... Im not to sure about this myself. You could probably tell that I was a bit reluctant to say yeah I'll give you a hand etc.

I still cant quite put my finger on it but it just seems a bit odd. I actually think that this is something that does not appeal to me. Best of luck on this though.

[was going to delete this but pros as much as cons are useful]

Last edited by Shinscar; 24th June 2008 at 21:50.. Reason: added note
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #29
cornelius blackfoot
 
cornelius blackfoot's Avatar
shins thats cool, right now I'm canvassing opinion if the people aren't feeling it, it may well die, or it may not. who knows
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #30
pj (pj)
i think this idea is, well, pretty corny.
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #31
cornelius blackfoot
 
cornelius blackfoot's Avatar
lol^^^^
I was hoping for the full of love, bright eyed and bushy tailed pj (pj), but instead I get a slightly subdued lake of darkness ;-P
  quote   reply
Old 24th June 2008   #32
pj (pj)
i''m tired and miserable today. i need to sleep, it is imminent.