Go Back   London Fixed-gear and Single-speed > Miscellaneous & Meaningless


 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 9th June 2008   #1
VelocityBoy
 
VelocityBoy's Avatar
Photography, lens reviews and opinions

I'm considering buying one of these:
Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 24-70mm f/2.8G ED

I'd love to know if anyone here has one, and if so what they think of it.

I'd also love to see some sample photos shot on it, high noise images (high ISO) would be appreciated as one of the primary uses will be low-light parties and gigs.
  quote   reply
Registered users don't see adverts. Signup or signin to hide them.
Old 9th June 2008   #2
MrSmith
 
MrSmith's Avatar
Blog Entries: 5
you are better off looking at low iso, low noise examples as noise will not help you see how the lense performs.
  quote   reply
Old 9th June 2008   #3
jonaent (Jon)
 
jonaent (Jon)'s Avatar
^^ +1
  quote   reply
Old 9th June 2008   #5
dicki
high iso will be very grainy best off doing it with low iso film
  quote   reply
Old 9th June 2008   #6
gizmond
 
gizmond's Avatar
I rented one of those for a while, they are a good lens but waaaaay pricey and pretty heavy, Check it out in a shop first, they are quite a lump to lug if you have a few in your bag.

Pretty fast lens, so would be good for gigs etc. But unless you need the zoom you can't beat the 50mm f1.4 for low light. (and or the 85mm 1.4)

Edit - Sorry it was the 28-70 that I rented, but I think the 24-70 is its successor.
  quote   reply
Old 9th June 2008   #7
Evilmonkey
Quote:
Originally Posted by gizmond View Post
Pretty fast lens, so would be good for gigs etc. But unless you need the zoom you can't beat the 50mm f1.4 for low light. (and or the 85mm 1.4)
The 50mmm 1.4 is the best lens I own by long way, and not too pricey second hand neither.
  quote   reply
Old 9th June 2008   #8
rusty
 
rusty's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Evilmonkey View Post
The 50mmm 1.4 is the best lens I own by long way, and not too pricey second hand neither.
+1
  quote   reply
Old 9th June 2008   #9
VelocityBoy
 
VelocityBoy's Avatar
I already have that lens.

I don't have a zoom, and the problem I've found with the prime is that there are many situations for which the prime is just a little ill-suited. I'm looking for a zoom to act as a prime replacement but still be incredibly strong in the prime range. And this lens seems to fit.

The bit I'm unsure about isn't size, weight, 70mm sharpness or even 50mm sharpness... but the pin cushion effect at the edges in the 24mm range.

I'd love to see similar use samples (gigs, parties) using the lens to try and determine whether it's an important reason not to buy or to wait a while longer.

That said, I hadn't considered one thing that has been mentioned on here... renting. I could just rent a lens and see. Seems a much better option than paying money without knowing.
  quote   reply
Old 9th June 2008   #10
fred
 
fred's Avatar
Blog Entries: 1
Quote:
Originally Posted by MrSmith View Post
you are better off looking at low iso, low noise examples as noise will not help you see how the lense performs.
true, but I think what he meant was what will his outfit perform like at high ISO.

@VB: the lens won't really affect how your camera performs in very low light, that's up to the sensor. However, the lens will determine how far you have to push the sensor, based on the amount of light it will let in. f2.8 isn't quite fast enough for "available light" shots at dark events (e.g. gigs etc). even at the limit of the sensor (which will be very noisy unless it's one of the latest models). For this you need something around f1.4, and you won't find an affordable zoom that goes to 1.4. But that's not to say it's a bad (or more importantly, a useful) lens.

24-70 is an excellent all-round lens and very versatile. But it depends what you have in your bag right now as to whether you should buy it, or get the 50mm first. If you have something in this range and need a lens specifically for low-available light work, then 50mm or even slightly wider fast prime might be money better spent.

EDIT: posted at the same time as your clarification. f2.8 isn't (IMO) fast enough. you can find easily out by using your 50mm at f2.8 or slower at the next gig ...
  quote   reply
Old 9th June 2008   #11
fred
 
fred's Avatar
Blog Entries: 1
Quote:
Originally Posted by VelocityBoy View Post
I already have that lens.

The bit I'm unsure about is... the pin cushion effect at the edges in the 24mm range.
check the reviews but you can fix this easily in post production - now we're (and I assume you are) digital, it's not the same problem as lack of sharpness, which can't really be fixed
  quote   reply
Old 9th June 2008   #12
fred
 
fred's Avatar
Blog Entries: 1
Quote:
Originally Posted by VelocityBoy View Post
That said, I hadn't considered one thing that has been mentioned on here... renting. I could just rent a lens and see. Seems a much better option than paying money without knowing.
better plan: borrow one for a couple of weeks...:-)
  quote   reply
Old 9th June 2008   #13
VelocityBoy
 
VelocityBoy's Avatar
The only thing I have in my bag is the 50mm f1.4 prime :)
  quote   reply
Old 9th June 2008   #14
VelocityBoy
 
VelocityBoy's Avatar
Oh, and the camera is a D80
  quote   reply
Old 9th June 2008   #15
fred
 
fred's Avatar
Blog Entries: 1
as per edit above: f2.8 isn't (IMO) fast enough for a low-available-light gig. you can find easily out by using your 50mm at f2.8 or slower at the next event...

I shoot events. All prime, slowest lens f2.0. Most of the time I work with 35mm f1.4 or 85mm f1.8. (on a full frame sensor), occasionally 50mm f1.4.

unless you wanna spend £££, then prime is your only real option, but that's just my opinion.

If you're looking for example shots, see here: http://www.flickr.com/groups/nikkor_24_70/

it reviews as a great lens*, but nothing on the flickr group from low-light events, which should tell you something.

*buy it :-)
  quote   reply

Bookmarks Shortcuts
Posts Categories

Tags
lens, photography
Registered users don't see adverts. Signup or signin to hide them.


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Non-digital fim photography and cameras GA2G Miscellaneous & Meaningless 89 18th July 2008 22:14
Simply awesome photography of man, bike and the world. Dylan General 9 22nd May 2008 09:44
Wanted: Photographers: Zoom Lens needed asap photoben Classifieds & Shopping 6 8th April 2008 22:40
Nikon portrait lens chris crash Miscellaneous & Meaningless 39 30th January 2008 11:22
Bike-related art/photography competition BringMeMyFix General 7 12th January 2008 05:47

Creative Commons License All times are GMT. The time now is 04:26.