Notices

 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 17th May 2009   #1
skelatordonor
 
skelator's Avatar
Wheel building - help calculating spoke length

i have used the damon rinard spoke length calculator exel spread sheet http://www.ctc.org.uk/DesktopDefault.aspx?TabID=3524 and have come up with 281.1 mm spokes.



for the wheel im using a on one front hub
large flange track hub
front
hub flange diameter: 61mm
flange distance: 34/34
locknut flange: 16mm

and a rigida dp18 rim, the measurements for which are in the calculator.

was going to order the spokes from parkers when i buy the rim to save postage, just wondered if someone with some experience of wheel building could run the measurements to make sure i have got it right and not messed up! i have laced a couple of wheels, but have no experience of purchasing spokes so any help would be greatly appreciated! plan is to lace and roughly true it, then hand it over to the lbs for fine truing, saving me pennies on wheel building!

its to match the wheel i have just purchased so i have a set to go on my new project, an old alan frame
  quote   reply
Old 17th May 2009   #2
_Zed_donor
 
_Zed_'s Avatar
Use Lenni's application to double check. www.lenni.me/edd
  quote   reply
Old 17th May 2009   #3
_Zed_donor
 
_Zed_'s Avatar
Quote:
but have no experience of purchasing spokes so any help would be greatly appreciated! plan is to lace and roughly true it, then hand it over to the lbs for fine truing, saving me pennies on wheel building!
phone and check with your LBS before you lace it up! they may not want to do this for you.

if you're lacing yourself anyway, just HTFU, read Sheldons instructions on how to true a wheel and you should be ok.
  quote   reply
Old 17th May 2009   #4
harv4130
 
harv4130's Avatar
take the hub and rim to LBS and get them to measure for the spokes, at the same time tell them what you are planning and see if they are up for it.

But you should give wheel building a go, I found the hardest bit was getting the hop out but practise (and patience) makes perfect (enough to miss the brake blocks!)
  quote   reply
Old 17th May 2009   #5
eyebrowsdonor
 
eyebrows's Avatar
when I'm lazy/ too busy i hand the wheels to be trued to the LBS, when not I don't.
saves a load of money.
  quote   reply
Old 17th May 2009   #6
skelatordonor
 
skelator's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ved View Post
phone and check with your LBS before you lace it up! they may not want to do this for you.

if you're lacing yourself anyway, just HTFU, read Sheldons instructions on how to true a wheel and you should be ok.
yeah have used sheldons instructions plenty of times, yeah the truing was just to save time but i have spoken to them and they are fine with it as long as it is laced correctly. will try the leni calculator anyway see what it says and if its miles different will get the lbs to measure up the spokes and get them there.
  quote   reply
Old 2nd July 2009   #7
Euro-vision
I've run the spoke calculator ... it's saying 280.7

So do I trade up to 282 spoke length or stretch in some 280's
  quote   reply
Old 2nd July 2009   #8
tee
 
tee's Avatar
Trade up to 282.
  quote   reply
Old 2nd July 2009   #9
mastershredder
what if the spoke length required is 292.4mm.

do i go 292mm or 294mm?
  quote   reply
Old 2nd July 2009   #10
rocker9455donor
 
rocker9455's Avatar
292, better shorter than longer
  quote   reply
Old 2nd July 2009   #11
ile
 
ile's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by mastershredder View Post
what if the spoke length required is 292.4mm.

do i go 292mm or 294mm?
Quote:
Originally Posted by rocker9455 View Post
292, better shorter than longer
That was the question I was wondering myself :-) So if calculator says 292.6 I should go for 292 rather than 294.
  quote   reply
Old 2nd July 2009   #12
BringMeMyFixdonor
 
BringMeMyFix's Avatar
Go whichever way puts you within 1mm of the spoke length given by the calculator.
  quote   reply
Old 4th July 2009   #13
arupdonor
 
arup's Avatar
I always tend to round down and usually take another mm off. Better to reach the recommended spoke tension and risk having a few threads showing rather than reach the end of the thread with the spoke still loose.
  quote   reply
Old 4th July 2009   #14
_Zed_donor
 
_Zed_'s Avatar
^ I have followed Arups advice too with great results.
  quote   reply
Old 4th July 2009   #15
BringMeMyFixdonor
 
BringMeMyFix's Avatar
It's a controversial subject. Not engaging enough threads in the nipple can cause problems. Being 1mm too long definitely won't.
  quote   reply
Old 4th July 2009   #16
n3lsondonor
 
n3lson's Avatar
That doesn't sound controversial.
  quote   reply
Old 4th July 2009   #17
BringMeMyFixdonor
 
BringMeMyFix's Avatar
Wheelbuilding is almost as contentious as religion. Someone's always going to wade in with their spoke stretch/round down/reaching end of thread opinions, to which they're entitled.

I'm sticking with this, if wanting to be absolutely sure of things:

- measure ERD of rim in 4 places, and take an average.
- run hub/rim measurements in 3 different spoke calcs, and take an average.
- round up or down to nearest spoke available within 1mm.

But there are more experts on forums like Weight Weenies than this one.
  quote   reply
Old 4th July 2009   #18
mitre_tester
 
mitre_tester's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by BringMeMyFix View Post
But there are more experts on forums like Weight Weenies than this one.
http://weightweenies.starbike.com/fo...hp?f=3&t=56170

The DT calculator is good
http://www.dtswiss.com/SpokesCalc/We...px?language=en

As long as you're not doing anything tricky (ultra-light rims, low spoke counts), bulding your own wheels is not rocket surgery. Modern spoke metallurgy makes them much more tolerant of amateur builders too.
  quote   reply
Old 9th July 2009   #19
mastershredder
I got a new required spoke length of 287.9mm.

do i go for 288mm or 286mm?

thanks
  quote   reply
Old 9th July 2009   #20
_Zed_donor
 
_Zed_'s Avatar
288
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2009   #21
Smallfurrydonor
 
Smallfurry's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by arup View Post
I always tend to round down and usually take another mm off. Better to reach the recommended spoke tension and risk having a few threads showing rather than reach the end of the thread with the spoke still loose.
Quote:
Originally Posted by BringMeMyFix View Post
It's a controversial subject. Not engaging enough threads in the nipple can cause problems. Being 1mm too long definitely won't.
Spoc calc gave me 290,3 to 291,3 for my current build (varies very slightly for disc brake sides, and short trials freehub side). I could only get even number spoke lenghs, so figured I'd round down to 290 (I tend to agree with arup, sorry BMMF).

Thing is, DT Swiss spoc calc assumed 12mm long nipples and I have 13mm ones. I'm curious to wether...

13mm nipple + 290 spoke = 12mm nipple + 291 spoke.

I'm sure its too little to matter. I just like to get things spot-on :)
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2009   #22
!Nhattattack!
 
!Nhattattack!'s Avatar
when in doubt, I always go for a longer nipple and a shorter spoke.
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2009   #23
dicki
 
dicki's Avatar
wise words nhatt - san
  quote   reply
Old 12th August 2009   #24
Smallfurrydonor
 
Smallfurry's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by !Nhattattack! View Post
when in doubt, I always go for a longer nipple and a shorter spoke.
Cool, that makes me near as makes no difference to spot-on. Bought some of these gimmicky things.

I was curious to wether I would be able to install a StansNoTubes strip over the top (when I can be bothered to attempt a conversion to tubeless). Belt and braces innit. If it dosent work I can just remove them for reuse.
  quote   reply

Bookmarks Shortcuts
Posts Categories

Tags
building, calculating, length, spoke, wheel


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Spoke length catboy1981 Mechanics & Fixin' 4 5th January 2009 00:46
Spoke length help Flex Mechanics & Fixin' 23 30th September 2008 20:21
Spoke Length Stefano Mechanics & Fixin' 22 7th March 2008 13:43
3l 3t spoke length chris crash Mechanics & Fixin' 9 6th February 2008 22:25
Spoke Length! GLoud Bikes & Bits 3 10th July 2007 14:35

Creative Commons License All times are GMT. The time now is 04:24.
no new posts
Page generated in 0.28808 seconds with 8 queries